A multivariate analysis to explain residue errors in pathogen concentration in wastewater-based epidemiology 鈥� Startseite 鈥� Leibniz 鲍苍颈惫别谤蝉颈迟盲迟 Hannover

A multivariate analysis to explain residue errors in pathogen concentration in wastewater-based epidemiology

verfasst von: Markus Wallner, Omar V. M眉ller, Andrea A. Gom茅z, Ingeborg Joost, Urda D眉ker, Frank Klawonn, Regina Nogueira
Abstract: With the beginning of the COVID-19 pandemic, wastewater-based epidemiology (WBE), which according to Larsen et al. (2021), describes the science of linking pathogens and chemicals found in wastewater to population-level health, received an enormous boost worldwide. The basic procedure in WBE is to analyse pathogen concentrations and to relate these measurements to cases from clinical data. This prediction of cases is subject to large errors, due to various factors such as dilution effects, decay or wastewater matrix and inhibitors. In this study we used different models to identify the most important, what we call, wastewater-based epidemiologically relevant parameters (WBERP) to describe these errors. We used linear regression and random forest regression as base models for predicting cases and random forest regression also to analyse the importance of different WBERP. Two catchments, one with a large proportion of combined sewers and one with separate sewers, served as study areas. Our results show that the most important information to be included in any model are the variants of concern (VOCs), a time-variable parameter. The performance for both catchments is improved by ~30 % in terms of root mean square error when the VOCs are used as additional information. For practical applications, this is a real drawback as it means that every time a new pathogen variant becomes dominant, we need to know the specific behaviour of the variant in the wastewater and its detection in order to interpret the WBE data correctly. This limits the predictive capabilities of such systems, perhaps not in terms of dynamics but for quantitative statements. The addition of other physicochemical parameters and faecal markers only marginally improved the results. Furthermore, there were differences in the importance of the parameters between the catchments, which limits the generalisability of the conclusions. The results show that more complex wastewater matrices (high proportion of combined sewer system) influence the relationship between pathogen concentration and medical cases more than those of less complex wastewater matrices (separate sewer system).
Organisationseinheit(en): Institut f眉r Siedlungswasserwirtschaft und Abfalltechnik
Externe Organisation(en): Ostfalia Hochschule f眉r angewandte Wissenschaften 鈥� Hochschule Braunschweig/Wolfenb眉ttel
Universidad Nacional del Litoral
Typ: Artikel
Journal: Science of the Total Environment
Band: 959
ISSN: 0048-9697
Publikationsdatum: 10.01.2025
Publikationsstatus: 痴别谤枚蹿蹿别苍迟濒颈肠丑迟
Peer-reviewed: Ja
ASJC Scopus Sachgebiete: Environmental engineering, Umweltchemie, Abfallwirtschaft und -entsorgung, Umweltverschmutzung
Elektronische Version(en): (Zugang: Offen)

BibTeX

@article{78f1a4d39e30457f95da2f94f3294d88,
title = "A multivariate analysis to explain residue errors in pathogen concentration in wastewater-based epidemiology",
abstract = "With the beginning of the COVID-19 pandemic, wastewater-based epidemiology (WBE), which according to Larsen et al. (2021), describes the science of linking pathogens and chemicals found in wastewater to population-level health, received an enormous boost worldwide. The basic procedure in WBE is to analyse pathogen concentrations and to relate these measurements to cases from clinical data. This prediction of cases is subject to large errors, due to various factors such as dilution effects, decay or wastewater matrix and inhibitors. In this study we used different models to identify the most important, what we call, wastewater-based epidemiologically relevant parameters (WBERP) to describe these errors. We used linear regression and random forest regression as base models for predicting cases and random forest regression also to analyse the importance of different WBERP. Two catchments, one with a large proportion of combined sewers and one with separate sewers, served as study areas. Our results show that the most important information to be included in any model are the variants of concern (VOCs), a time-variable parameter. The performance for both catchments is improved by ~30 % in terms of root mean square error when the VOCs are used as additional information. For practical applications, this is a real drawback as it means that every time a new pathogen variant becomes dominant, we need to know the specific behaviour of the variant in the wastewater and its detection in order to interpret the WBE data correctly. This limits the predictive capabilities of such systems, perhaps not in terms of dynamics but for quantitative statements. The addition of other physicochemical parameters and faecal markers only marginally improved the results. Furthermore, there were differences in the importance of the parameters between the catchments, which limits the generalisability of the conclusions. The results show that more complex wastewater matrices (high proportion of combined sewer system) influence the relationship between pathogen concentration and medical cases more than those of less complex wastewater matrices (separate sewer system).",
keywords = "Machine learning, Random forest, SARS-CoV-2, Wastewater-based epidemiology",
author = "Markus Wallner and M{\"u}ller, {Omar V.} and Gom{\'e}z, {Andrea A.} and Ingeborg Joost and Urda D{\"u}ker and Frank Klawonn and Regina Nogueira",
note = "Publisher Copyright: {\textcopyright} 2024",
year = "2025",
month = jan,
day = "10",
doi = "10.1016/j.scitotenv.2024.178149",
language = "English",
volume = "959",
journal = "Science of the Total Environment",
issn = "0048-9697",
publisher = "Elsevier",
}

麻豆官网

A multivariate analysis to explain residue errors in pathogen concentration in wastewater-based epidemiology